Q: Can I use canned pure pumpkin in place of butternut squash?

Yes, canned pure pumpkin is an excellent substitute for pureed cooked butternut squash (like in soups, breads, or pies). Commercially canned pumpkin is typically made from smooth-fleshed squash varieties and offers a very consistent texture. However, it is generally milder and less sweet than roasted butternut squash. Use a 1:1 ratio by volume for purees, but be prepared to add extra sweetener (like maple syrup) or savory seasoning to achieve the depth of flavor butternut squash naturally provides. Remember: look for 100% pure pumpkin, not pumpkin pie filling!

Q: <strong>What's the substitution ratio I should use in place of the butternut squash?</strong>

As a general rule, you can use a 1:1 ratio by weight . If a recipe calls for one medium butternut squash, you can typically substitute with one medium kabocha, two delicata squashes, or a large sweet potato, depending on the specific recipe's needs, and depending on the ratio by weight. Check out the profiles for each butternut squash substitute profiled in the sections above.

Question 1

Can I use canned pure pumpkin in place of butternut squash?

Accepted Answer

Yes, canned pure pumpkin is an excellent substitute for pureed cooked butternut squash (like in soups, breads, or pies). Commercially canned pumpkin is typically made from smooth-fleshed squash varieties and offers a very consistent texture.

However, it is generally milder and less sweet than roasted butternut squash. Use a 1:1 ratio by volume for purees, but be prepared to add extra sweetener (like maple syrup) or savory seasoning to achieve the depth of flavor butternut squash naturally provides. Remember: look for 100% pure pumpkin, not pumpkin pie filling!

Question 2

Are any of these substitutes lower in carbs than butternut squash?

Accepted Answer

Generally, many of the squash varieties listed (like kabocha or delicata) have similar carbohydrate profiles to butternut. Sweet potatoes tend to be slightly higher in carbs. If you're looking for a significantly lower-carb option, you might consider something like roasted cauliflower or even celeriac, though their flavor and texture will be very different and would require more significant recipe adjustments.

Question 3

What's the substitution ratio I should use in place of the butternut squash?

Accepted Answer

As a general rule, you can use a 1:1 ratio by weight. If a recipe calls for one medium butternut squash, you can typically substitute with one medium kabocha, two delicata squashes, or a large sweet potato, depending on the specific recipe's needs, and depending on the ratio by weight.

Check out the profiles for each butternut squash substitute profiled in the sections above.

Ingredient Guides

Butternut Squash Substitutes: How to Choose the Right One for Your Recipe

A Guide to Sunflower Sprouts

When Are Blood Oranges in Season?

A Guide to Rainbow Chard

The Definitive Guide to Thai Eggplant: Varieties, Prep and Global Uses

3 Common Dragon Fruit Varieties (Pitaya)

A Complete List of Microgreens, Shoots and Sprouts

5 Fall Spices That Aren’t Pumpkin Spice

Figs 101: A Beginner’s Guide

5 Easy Ways to Use Fresh Herbs Daily (+Recipes)